Now onboarding AuriaTrack consultants · Become a Consultant →
Guide

Comparing Ad Networks
by Revenue, Not Clicks.

Every ad network has a dashboard that makes it look like the smart choice. Cheap clicks on one, a low cost per lead on another, huge reach on a third. None of those numbers tells you which network paid for itself. Here is how to compare them on the only figures that line up across all of them: what each customer cost, and what each dollar returned.

Five Networks, Five Different Jobs

These are the networks AuriaTrack works with for service businesses. Each one reaches people at a different moment, and each charges for something different. The roles below are typical, not rules — your market, offer and setup can change them.

Google Search

Intent capture. You bid on what people type, so the ad appears when someone is already looking for a plumber, a roofer or a med spa. You generally pay per click. Clicks can be expensive in competitive trades, because everyone wants that same searcher.

Google Local Services Ads

Intent capture at the very top of the results page for many service categories. Instead of paying per click, you are generally charged per lead — typically a call or message — which makes its cost look nothing like a search campaign's on paper.

Meta (Facebook & Instagram)

Usually demand creation. People are scrolling, not searching, so the ad has to make them want something they were not looking for yet. Many campaign types charge by impressions, and in-app lead forms make it very easy to become a lead — which cuts both ways.

Microsoft Advertising

Intent capture on Bing and its partner sites, with a keyword model much like Google's. It can bring lower cost per click with less competition, on a smaller volume of searches, and its audience will not be identical to Google's.

Outbrain (native)

Demand creation inside publisher sites, as recommended articles and content. Readers are browsing, so the click is curiosity rather than a purchase decision. It tends to work as an introduction, with the sale arriving later and often through another channel.

Why Cost Per Click Is the Wrong Yardstick

Cost per click compares the price of the ticket, not the destination. A click from someone searching “emergency plumber near me” and a click from someone who tapped an interesting article on a news site are both one click. One of them is standing in water. Putting their prices side by side and calling the cheaper one the better deal is how budgets drift toward traffic that never buys.

It gets worse once the networks stop charging for the same thing. Local Services Ads mostly bill per lead, Meta often bills per thousand impressions, search bills per click. There is no single “cost per click” to compare across all five, so any table that lines them up on CPC is mixing units.

Cost per lead is closer, but still not the answer. Each platform defines a lead its own way, and some leads are far easier to produce than others: a pre-filled form inside an app takes two taps, a phone call takes intent. A network can look like the cheapest source of leads and the most expensive source of customers at the same time. That gap is covered in more depth in Is My Cost Per Lead Any Good? and, for the Meta side specifically, Facebook Says 40 Leads. You Got 12.

Finally, every network counts its own conversions, by its own rules, with its own attribution window. Add up what each one claims and the total is often more than the customers you actually got, because the same person can be claimed by two or three networks at once. Their dashboards are useful for steering inside each network. They were never designed to referee between them.

Comparing Networks on Your Own Closed Deals

The fair comparison uses one referee for every network: your own record of who became a paying customer. Here is the order to build it in.

1
Tag every lead with the network that sent it

Every form, call and message needs a source attached at the moment it arrives — from UTM tags, click IDs like gclid and fbclid, and tracking numbers for calls. A lead with no source cannot be credited to anyone, and phone-heavy businesses lose the most here.

2
Record every closed deal against its lead

When a job is won, it should be matched to the lead that started it, with the revenue attached. That match is the whole point: without it, you are comparing networks on activity, not outcomes.

3
Use the same date range and the same spend source

Pull each network's spend for the same period, and compare it against leads that arrived in that period. Mixing click dates on one side with close dates on the other quietly flatters whichever network has the longer cycle.

4
Calculate cost per customer for each network

Spend on the network, divided by the number of new paying customers whose lead came from it. This is the number that lines up across every network, however each one bills.

5
Calculate revenue per dollar for each network

Revenue from those customers, divided by spend on the network — return on ad spend. Cost per customer tells you what you paid; revenue per dollar tells you whether the jobs were worth it, because one network can bring smaller jobs than another.

6
Give slower networks time before judging them

Judge a month of leads only once most of them have had a fair chance to close. Then check the result again a month or two later. A network that looks weak on the first pass can look very different when its slower customers arrive.

Small numbers swing hard. If a network produced three customers this quarter, one more or one fewer moves its cost per customer by a third. Before cutting a network on a single period, look at a longer window, and treat a small sample as a reason to keep watching rather than a verdict. Try the cost-per-customer calculator and the ROAS calculator on each network's numbers.

Sales Cycles and Assists Change the Answer

A fair comparison does not stop at last-click revenue. Networks that create demand rarely get the final click, and their customers often take longer to decide.

Different cycle lengths

Someone with a burst pipe books today. Someone who saw a kitchen remodel video may call in six weeks. If you compare networks on a short window, the intent-capture networks will win almost by default, because their customers close before the report runs.

First touch versus last touch

A customer might first meet you through a Meta video, then search your name on Google weeks later and click a search ad. Last-touch reporting gives Google all of it. Keeping the first touch alongside the last shows which network started the conversation.

Branded search borrows credit

Searches for your business name are often people who already decided, perhaps because of an ad elsewhere. Separate branded from non-branded campaigns before comparing, or search will look stronger than it is and the networks that sent those people weaker.

Networks work in combination

Cutting a demand-creation network can slowly shrink the searches the intent-capture networks feed on. If you pause one, watch the others for the next couple of months before deciding the cut was free.

None of this means demand-creation networks are secretly the best performers. Sometimes a network really does produce leads that never become customers, and the right move is to cut it. The point is that you can only tell the difference with closed deals tied to the lead, a window long enough for your slower customers, and a view of more than one touch. For what that looks like across a whole customer journey, see tracking offline and online touchpoints.

One Referee for Every Network

This is the comparison AuriaTrack is built to make. Our team plans, builds and runs campaigns across Google, Meta, Microsoft Advertising and Outbrain, and the tracking script on your site stores UTMs and click IDs in first-party cookies with a write-once first-touch record, so every lead carries its source and the network that first introduced it. Won deals sync in from GoHighLevel, Square, ServiceTitan, Housecall Pro, Jobber or a CSV and are matched back to the lead that started them.

The result is a side-by-side view of the platforms on cost per lead, cost per closed deal and return on ad spend, all measured against the same set of customers rather than each network's own conversion count. On the Ascent and Summit plans, call tracking ties phone leads to their campaign, Google Local Services Ads leads are tracked alongside every other source, and real revenue is sent back to Meta and Google so their bidding learns from paying customers. Plan details are on the pricing page.

For the wider argument behind this approach, read platform ROI versus click metrics, or see how attribution works →

What People Ask About Comparing Networks

Which ad network is best for a local service business?
There is no universal answer. Search and Local Services Ads tend to reach people who are already looking, and Meta and native ads tend to reach people before they are. Which one pays best for you depends on your trade, market, offer and how fast your customers decide — which is why it is worth measuring on your own closed deals.
Why can't I just compare cost per click across networks?
Because a click means something different on each one, and not every network charges per click. Local Services Ads generally bill per lead and many Meta campaigns bill by impressions. Cost per customer and revenue per dollar are the figures that line up across all of them.
Why do my ad platforms claim more conversions than I have customers?
Each platform counts conversions by its own rules and window, and several can claim the same person. Counting customers once, in your own records, and crediting each to its source is the only way to get a total that adds up.
How long should I wait before judging a network?
Long enough for most of a period's leads to have had a fair chance to close, which depends on your sales cycle. Compare a month of leads once that time has passed, and re-check it later, so slower-closing networks are not judged before their customers arrive.
Should I cut a network that never gets the last click?
Not on that basis alone. Check whether its leads show up as a first touch for customers who later converted through search. If it neither starts nor finishes any paying customer's journey over a reasonable window, then cutting it is a fair call.

See Which Network Actually Pays You

Book a demo and we'll look at what each of your ad networks costs you per customer, not per click.